September 02 2010 17:22:11
Navigation
· Home
· Discussion Forum
· News Categories
· Staff Page
· Search
· RSS Feeds
· Ultimate Stat Page
· Links
· Contact
· Voice Your Opinion
News Feeds




Welcome
Banning Christmas and Halloween

Advert
US News Share
According to the Chicago Sun Times, school districts in Oak Lawn, Illinois, are considering banning holiday traditions that are offensive to Muslims. The decisions will be made in the next few weeks and will be rendered by the principals of five Ridgeland schools.

Supt. of Schools Tom Smyth was quoted as saying, "We have to think about our purpose. Are we about teaching reading, writing and math or for parties or fund-raising during the day?"

Many parents feel this announcement will agitate members of this community, as decisions earlier this month were made to change the school's menu to exclude items containing pork.

Police on Wednesday responded to a call of a shouting match among parents regarding the schools holiday debate.

School officials are hoping to reach agreements to please all the students and parents involved.
Comments
#1 | Oldfart on October 02 2007 16:17:50
I often wondered why I couldn't get a good pork fried rice in Chicago. Still, it is the city of barbecued ribs. Hopefully the Muslim threat hasn't gotten to the ribs. What is also very good is the Italian Beef - something that, along with Green River shakes, just doesn't exist here near Kansas City.Angry

I have no idea why these schools should suddenly start caring about offending Muslims. They never cared before. Do they have large Muslim populations or something? I don't recall Oak Lawn as being a Muslim enclave but I guess that is possible.
#2 | ethwc on October 02 2007 16:43:04
I wonder why the schools are justifying this based on not offending Islamists. Haven't a number of the more conservative Christian sects objected to Halloween celebrations based upon its possible Wiccan heritage?
#3 | rwahrens on October 02 2007 18:21:34
LOL!

Almost all high Christian holidays, including Christmas, have pagan roots! Suborning pagan holidays was one method used by the RCC to force its way into the various parts of Europe and Britain. It was the only way they could get pagan populations to celebrate Christian holidays!

Still, this is ridiculous. If children can't eat pork they offer an alternative. If, like Orthodox Jews, they can't eat school lunches because the kitchens don't meet kosher rules, then they can bring their own lunches.

Simple. It was not only that they didn't care before, but the Jews obey almost the exact same dietary rules, and I'll bet they never blinked an eyelash over offending Jews, huh?

Stupid political correctness gone overboard. Sad
#4 | FifthofNovember on October 03 2007 02:21:55
...And the terrorists win again...
#5 | Timothy Shay on October 03 2007 03:11:46
At least they're thinking ahead in Oak Lawn. It's a small world growing smaller. In egalitarian democratic states like the US and Canada religious belief systems and their attached holidays should be activities limited to the home and marketplace not schools or other public institutions. Your founding fathers knew this. The Jeffersonian Bible was created by Jefferson when he literally snipped out all references to god, miracle, resurrection, angels, spirits and virgin birth from the New Testament.. It reads like simple straight forward philosophy.
#6 | rwahrens on October 03 2007 09:14:04
Tim, in the US, Christmas has become as much a secular holiday as anything. My daughter and her husband, staunch Catholics, refuse to celebrate using any rituals outside of the religious aspects of it because they feel it is TOO secular!

Plus, Halloween has always been secular, and has never had any overtly religious connotations here.

Thus, I see no reason why these two holidays should be banned. They are legitimate social holidays here, and do not require anyone to do anything that would violate religious taboos.

In the elevated atmosphere that has generated law suits from non-Christians over religious observations in schools, these two holidays have generated noe at al that I know of. So nobody else has been insulted by them.

So what's the problem?
#7 | rwahrens on October 03 2007 09:15:16
AAACK! Stupid lack of editing features!

noe = none
#8 | ethwc on October 03 2007 09:39:16
The origins of Halloween are from Celtic ceremonies on what they called Samhain. This was a religious festival tied in with Druidic religious activities. The Romans in attempting to pacify the Celts and to further their state religion (Christianity) modified this to All Saints Day. Children being children prefer a fun life and are probably closer to the original than was the church.

For a brief discussion of this history, see

http://www.histor...pageId=713
#9 | Timothy Shay on October 03 2007 15:21:21
Samhain/Hallowe'en is currently celebrated as a religious feast by organized Wiccans worldwide. Wicca is a growing religion. Christmas, though secularized has a great combo of Christian and Pagan content. Because the basic festival has been rooted in the birth of Christ, (for one thousand plus years), it should not be celebrated in public schools. That is not saying that a mid winter festival should not occur in schools. Most religions and cultures have celebrated a mid winter feast at the darkest point of the year. I mean you can wish anyone seasonal greetings and still respect their personal interpretations of the content of their celebration outside of public school. Secularized holidays, especially gift giving consumerist events tend to disclude those of other religious persuasions, (eg./ Jehovah's Witnesses), and most importantly the poor and underprivileged. I'm not saying we should abandon festivals but in a true democracy separation of church and state must be rigorous. I'm sure, after seeing the oppressions which occur in Islamic Republics the good ol' US should shudder at the gloomy possibilities of a Christian Republic.
#10 | rwahrens on October 03 2007 17:42:11
Actually, Tim, Christianity didn't hit upon the December date for the birth of Christ until after the 4th century. Originally, it was a celebration of the birth of the god Mithras, from which at least some of Christian theology was borrowed.

Other cultures have used that rough period for solar worshiping celebrations based upon the winter equinox, where the days begin getting shorter, as they celebrate the return of the sun from its winter retreat.
Post Comment
Please Login to Post a Comment.
Ratings
Rating is available to Members only.

Please login or register to vote.

No Ratings have been Posted.
Latest Articles
Last 10 Comments
Vanity Fair Journalist Bashes Sarah Palin in Scathing Article
13169 I am an English professor of over twenty years. I am published, no New York Times best seller, yet, but some of my stories are popular sellers. I enjoy a lot of inside connections within my writers - PurlGurl
Constitution and the Ground Zero Mosque
13132 Excellent piece. Thanks for taking the time to write it. - MplsVala
Sex on TV linked to teen pregnancy
7475 I too agree because The [u - jenifer111
ABC's 9-11 Movie
105 ABC is good channel. Its recently aired show[u - jenifer111
Newspapers vs. Internet
8877 I too agree with this point. Newspapers are no longer reliable and dying in their popularity. Internet is the fast pace medium to read the live news. I usually read about tv shows from here. I like in - jenifer111
Steven Slater: A Working-Class Hero?
13110 Well I guess same about it.. - jenifer111
Constitution and the Ground Zero Mosque
13132 Amen. I doubt very much that the writers intended for habeas corpus to be suspended while fighting a nebulous war against a criminal international group. Al Queda is an organization of evil doers bu - ethwc
E-Readers: Technologically Savvy or Just Lazy?
13143 One has choices for the device to be used. I, for one have refused to pay 300 or more for a reader and use my regular PC with software downloaded for free from Amazon. Literally thousands of books a - ethwc
Constitution and the Ground Zero Mosque
13132 Ed, I applaud your essay, I could not have said it better. I would add, however, that the Constitution DOES give the President the power to suspend habeus corpus in the cases of invasion or of insu - rwahrens
What To Do With Iran?
13133 Well Ethwc, it's going to be tough to deal with Iran now. What should have been done years ago was to allow Israel to go in there and bomb the nuclear plant while it was still being built. But - Anthony W Leone
Most Recent Opinion Pieces
Political Motives For Iraq Withdraw?
Attack On Muslim Cabbie Doesn’t Add Up
ABBEY ROAD:
Some Good Memories
What To Do With Iran?
Constitution and the Ground Zero Mosque
France to Expel Roma Amidst Mounting Criticism
Free Gaza
Can homegrown terrorism be stopped? Or is it a pipe dream?
Cal and the Tea Party
Government Motors (GM)
BP Hedges on Role of Relief Well in Gulf Oil Leak
Arizona's Immigration Law
Who Was the Real Hero of 1910 Bombing of The Los Angeles Times
Is Healthy Good for the Country?
Arizona, Immigration and Lack of Care
Book Review: An Irish Country Village
The beginning of the end for Chrysler
Is Netanyahu Blowing The Usual Smoke?
Why is the “The Twilight Saga” film series so popular?
Natural Disasters, Insurance and the Federal Government
Login
Username

Password



Not a member yet?
Click here to register.

Forgotten your password?
Request a new one here.
Adverts
Top Stories Past 7 Days
You have an error in your SQL syntax; check the manual that corresponds to your MySQL server version for the right syntax to use near ')group by comment_item_id order by a desc limit 10' at line 1You have an error in your SQL syntax; check the manual that corresponds to your MySQL server version for the right syntax to use near ')group by comment_item_id order by a desc limit 10' at line 1
You have an error in your SQL syntax; check the manual that corresponds to your MySQL server version for the right syntax to use near ')group by comment_item_id order by a desc limit 10' at line 1