September 02 2010 17:20:11
Navigation
· Home
· Discussion Forum
· News Categories
· Staff Page
· Search
· RSS Feeds
· Ultimate Stat Page
· Links
· Contact
· Voice Your Opinion
News Feeds




Welcome
Another Republican Senator Breaks With President on Iraq

Advert
US News Share
by Michael S. Leonard

WASHINGTON, July 5—Senator Pete Domenici today voiced his opposition to the president’s Iraq strategy, joining the growing chorus of Republicans who have openly criticized the war in recent weeks, according to The New York Times. Though he refused to endorse the withdrawal plan advocated by Congressional Democrats, Mr. Domenici issued what amounts to an announcement of “no confidence” in the prosecution of the war that has become a signature issue of the Republican Party and its unpopular president.

“We cannot continue asking our troops to sacrifice indefinitely while the Iraqi government is not making measurable progress,” said Mr. Domenici, who is up for reelection in 2008.

The announcement follows by approximately a week similar statements by Senators Richard Lugar (R-Indiana) and George Voinovich (R-Ohio). Supporters of the war worry it may validate their concerns that Senator Lugar’s wavering could signal a coming tidal wave of Republican defections. Senators Lugar, Voinovich, and Domenici were all staunch war supporters before their recent statements, which began last week with a Lugar oration on the Senate floor.

In addition to Senators Lugar, Voinovich and Domenici, Senator John Warner of Virginia, former chair of the Armed Services Committee, has been a war critic since last fall. Like Mr. Domenici, Mr. Warner, whose criticism has been occasionally vocal but mainly subdued, is up for reelection next year.

The war poses a thorny political problem for Republicans, who lost their majorities in both houses of Congress last November in a stunning electoral defeat that voters and commentators alike have largely attributed to their affiliation with the Iraq war, which most Americans now consider a failed and expensive quagmire. Republicans facing reelection campaigns must try to distance themselves from President Bush on the war, but most seem reluctant to embrace the Democratic plan. Instead, they are trying to stake out some kind of middle ground, but it remains unclear exactly what they are proposing.

“I’m not calling for an immediate withdrawal from Iraq or a reduction in funding for our troops, but I am calling for a new strategy that will move our troops out of combat operations and on the path to continuing home,” Mr. Domenici said.

The timing of the recent announcements is significant. Congressional Democrats are preparing to reintroduce the war as a political issue next week, when a number of Pentagon appropriations bills will be up for a vote. The Democratic Party leadership is planning to tie the budget bills to their plan for a series of mandatory withdrawal deadlines, and mounting criticism of the war from such prominent and senior Republicans could provide political cover for a wave of defections by Republicans eager to rid themselves of the war issue.

Any bill to end the occupation and redeploy the bulk of U.S. troops would likely have to be a compromise in order to ensure the bipartisan support necessary to override a presidential veto. But many Democrats, who recently capitulated to a veto on a supplemental spending bill that included withdrawal deadlines, have expressed optimism that they could be working toward a veto-proof bloc of antiwar votes as Republicans continue to break ranks with President Bush.

“Beginning with the defense authorization bill next week, Republicans will have the opportunity to not just say the right things on Iraq, but vote the right way, too, so that we can bring the responsible end to this war that the American people demand and deserve,” said Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nevada).

Still, some antiwar Democrats have expressed skepticism about the sincerity of the Republican criticism. They worry that they may not have the Republican support they need to end the war, even with significant concessions. Senators Lugar, Voinovich, and Domenici have refused to embrace withdrawal dates but have opposed an open-ended occupation. This contradiction, coupled with the vagueness of the criticism, has led to some accusations that the defections amount to an empty political ploy, an attempt to dissociate the Republican brand from the war in time for next year’s election without actually taking concrete measures to end it.

Senator Domenici may be particularly vulnerable in 2008 because of his affiliation with the United States attorney scandal engulfing the Justice Department. Domenici is reported to have consulted with presidential advisor Karl Rove regarding the ouster of U.S. attorney David Iglesias after he refused to pursue politically motivated accusations against a prominent Democrat, calling them baseless. Domenici has denied any wrongdoing.
Comments
#1 | seaman93555 on July 06 2007 18:03:29
This contradiction, coupled with the vagueness of the criticism, has led to some accusations that the defections amount to an empty political ploy, an attempt to dissociate the Republican brand from the war in time for next year’s election without actually taking concrete measures to end it.


Great article and I think the quote from this article that I have included with this post is the reason behind the change in direction. I suppose, when you are running for re-election, distance in this case has its merits.
#2 | sol on July 09 2007 07:05:40
Another congressman criticizing the war today...more U.S. casualties today in Iraq…another congressman criticizing the war today...more U.S. casualties today in Iraq…another congressman criticizing the war today...more U.S. casualties today in Iraq…another congressman criticizing the war today...more U.S. casualties today in Iraq…another congressman criticizing the war today...more U.S. casualties today in Iraq… When will this madness end?
Post Comment
Please Login to Post a Comment.
Ratings
Rating is available to Members only.

Please login or register to vote.

No Ratings have been Posted.
Latest Articles
Last 10 Comments
Vanity Fair Journalist Bashes Sarah Palin in Scathing Article
13169 I am an English professor of over twenty years. I am published, no New York Times best seller, yet, but some of my stories are popular sellers. I enjoy a lot of inside connections within my writers - PurlGurl
Constitution and the Ground Zero Mosque
13132 Excellent piece. Thanks for taking the time to write it. - MplsVala
Sex on TV linked to teen pregnancy
7475 I too agree because The [u - jenifer111
ABC's 9-11 Movie
105 ABC is good channel. Its recently aired show[u - jenifer111
Newspapers vs. Internet
8877 I too agree with this point. Newspapers are no longer reliable and dying in their popularity. Internet is the fast pace medium to read the live news. I usually read about tv shows from here. I like in - jenifer111
Steven Slater: A Working-Class Hero?
13110 Well I guess same about it.. - jenifer111
Constitution and the Ground Zero Mosque
13132 Amen. I doubt very much that the writers intended for habeas corpus to be suspended while fighting a nebulous war against a criminal international group. Al Queda is an organization of evil doers bu - ethwc
E-Readers: Technologically Savvy or Just Lazy?
13143 One has choices for the device to be used. I, for one have refused to pay 300 or more for a reader and use my regular PC with software downloaded for free from Amazon. Literally thousands of books a - ethwc
Constitution and the Ground Zero Mosque
13132 Ed, I applaud your essay, I could not have said it better. I would add, however, that the Constitution DOES give the President the power to suspend habeus corpus in the cases of invasion or of insu - rwahrens
What To Do With Iran?
13133 Well Ethwc, it's going to be tough to deal with Iran now. What should have been done years ago was to allow Israel to go in there and bomb the nuclear plant while it was still being built. But - Anthony W Leone
Most Recent Opinion Pieces
Political Motives For Iraq Withdraw?
Attack On Muslim Cabbie Doesn’t Add Up
ABBEY ROAD:
Some Good Memories
What To Do With Iran?
Constitution and the Ground Zero Mosque
France to Expel Roma Amidst Mounting Criticism
Free Gaza
Can homegrown terrorism be stopped? Or is it a pipe dream?
Cal and the Tea Party
Government Motors (GM)
BP Hedges on Role of Relief Well in Gulf Oil Leak
Arizona's Immigration Law
Who Was the Real Hero of 1910 Bombing of The Los Angeles Times
Is Healthy Good for the Country?
Arizona, Immigration and Lack of Care
Book Review: An Irish Country Village
The beginning of the end for Chrysler
Is Netanyahu Blowing The Usual Smoke?
Why is the “The Twilight Saga” film series so popular?
Natural Disasters, Insurance and the Federal Government
Login
Username

Password



Not a member yet?
Click here to register.

Forgotten your password?
Request a new one here.
Adverts
Top Stories Past 7 Days
You have an error in your SQL syntax; check the manual that corresponds to your MySQL server version for the right syntax to use near ')group by comment_item_id order by a desc limit 10' at line 1You have an error in your SQL syntax; check the manual that corresponds to your MySQL server version for the right syntax to use near ')group by comment_item_id order by a desc limit 10' at line 1
You have an error in your SQL syntax; check the manual that corresponds to your MySQL server version for the right syntax to use near ')group by comment_item_id order by a desc limit 10' at line 1