November 20 2009 17:52:50
Navigation
· Home
· Discussion Forum
· News Categories
· Staff Page
· Search
· RSS Feeds
· Ultimate Stat Page
· Links
· Contact
· Voice Your Opinion
News Feeds




Welcome
Ethics and the Nobel Prize for Literature

Advert
Opinions Share
Visit: Author's Website


It's no secret that Nobel Prizes are awarded at least partially on political merits. Obama's recent award caused mass outrage and confusion, and his is scarcely the first. However, with all the spotlight on his award this year, I can't help but worry that, once again, the inherent bias of the Nobel Prize for literature will be swept under the table.

I almost feel as I though I am a broken record spouting this stuff- the conversation comes up almost every year, but dissipates just as quickly.

For years now, the literature prize has gone almost exclusively to Europeans. It's certainly true that there are authors from other continents among the ranks of the victors, but in terms of percentages and proportionality both it's almost unarguable that there is a European bias among the awards. The most recent streak stretches back to at least 2000, depending on whether you consider Gao Xingjian to qualify as a French or Chinese author.

It's most certainly true that authors have been denied the award for political reasons. Celebrated writers from Tolstoy to Borges have failed to receive it, and doubtlessly even the greatest literary snobs among us would consider them to have made enormous contributions to the literary world.

As a result, the prize is increasing devalued, and the bias seems to become worse every year.

To be frank, I cannot claim to be familiar with the writings of Herta Muller, this year's winner, but I have no doubt that her writing has some value to it. That said, I have to wonder. Was she really more deserving than Philip Roth or Amos Oz? Both names tend to carry more weight in the literary world. I have the sneaking suspicion that there are even some who would think Murakami Haruki more worthy, despite the large scale failings his writing suffers in translation.

Hopefully, the committee will smarten up and diversify their winner next year. Otherwise, fewer and fewer will come to respect the award, and without legitimacy, it really isn't worthy anything.
Comments
No Comments have been Posted.
Post Comment
Please Login to Post a Comment.
Ratings
Rating is available to Members only.

Please login or register to vote.

No Ratings have been Posted.
Latest Articles
Last 10 Comments
Have They No Shame . . .
11019 seaman93555 - How could anyone forget Senator Kennedy and Health Care Reform so soon? Maybe your agenda has clouded your memory a little? You do not have to look far for other examples. - Peacemaker
Robert Byrd Becomes Longest-Serving Congress Member
11902 [b]How about his stand on Civil Rights! Yeah - Long and Productive.. Senator Robert Byrd (D) opposed the Civil Rights act, we all know this guy right? I mean he is still someone the Dems all loo - Peacemaker
Who Owns the Moon?
11867 Seems the only answer to this question is war...after all it's the "American Way". - Timothy Shay
CIA Seeks U.S. Arabs With New TV Spot
11908 The November 19 column of Obsidian Wings (see it at [u - ethwc
Reid Remains Optimistic on New Health Care Bill
11901 Now that I got that off my chest, I would like to discuss what I believe to be the crux of the health care reform debate. Today, on Alternet, there is a diatribe about insurance companies ongoing den - ethwc
Reid Remains Optimistic on New Health Care Bill
11901 He needs 51 votes to pass the bill. He needs 60 only in the event of a filibuster. While this may be a technicality, it is a fact and it would be nice if we were able to deal in facts at least in so - ethwc
Abortion Rights Attacked by New Health Care Bill
11841 [quote]This provision needs to be stripped in reconciliation.[/quote] Why? So I (Joe Blow taxpayer) will be forced into paying for others elective surgeries?? - BoilerUp
Catholic Church Threatens Washington, D.C. on Same-Sex Marriage
11866 You got it in one! - rwahrens
Who Owns the Moon?
11867 touche humans have always handled expansion the same way...isn't going to change now or in the future. what about all this busienss w/ antarctica? it would be the first - and last - contine - showerjuggernaut
Catholic Church Threatens Washington, D.C. on Same-Sex Marriage
11866 I might consider accepting such sillliness were God to say it for itself. However, when I am told what God intends to be said and that intention is interpreted by self appointed emissaries, I tend to - ethwc
Most Recent Opinion Pieces
Who Owns the Moon?
Women Behaving Badly
Arguing over abortion…haven’t we heard this before?
Will the Droid be an iPhone Killer?
So Bloomberg bought a public office. Your point is…?
Sex sells, but do you have to sell it while I'm eating dinner?
Bloomburg Wins - Using the Power of Money
The Beginning Of The End For Dems
Lessons we won’t take away from Balloon Boy incident
Does "God, the Father" Lead to the Supression of Women?
Hate crime legislation
Controlled scientific experiment
China and North Korea: Finding an Equilibrium
Caveat Emptor
Is This Progress?
Ethics and the Nobel Prize for Literature
WALLOWING IN PESSIMISM
Happy 17th Wedding Anniversary To the Obama’s!
A case of disgraceful bank conduct
An aritst who takes one's breath away
Advertisers
Login
Username

Password



Not a member yet?
Click here to register.

Forgotten your password?
Request a new one here.
Adverts
Top Stories Past 7 Days
Who Owns the Moon? 8
Catholic Church Threatens Washington, D.C. on Same-Sex Marriage 6
Abortion Rights Attacked by New Health Care Bill 5
An Abundance of Water Found on Lunar South Pole of Moon 2
Reid Remains Optimistic on New Health Care Bill 2
An aritst who takes one's breath away 2
China Warns Obama Against Meeting Dalai Lama 2
Apple Reverses Its Decision on Political iPhone Application 2
Rumors Swirling About Apple’s Potential Black Friday Discounts 1
Have They No Shame . . . 1